Share this record: 𝕏 Post on X f Facebook
💀 KILLED IN SENATE — March 24, 2026 · H 760 Did Not Pass
← Active Bills HB 659 (ICE — Killed) S 1260 (Immigration)
Introduced
Committee
House Vote
Senate Cmte
Killed — Senate
Governor
💀 Failed on 17-17 Senate Tie — March 24, 2026
H 760 failed in the Idaho Senate on a 17-17 tie vote on March 24, 2026. Under Idaho Senate rules, a tie vote fails. President Pro Tem Kelly Anthon (R-District 27, Rupert) voted NAY — one of 17 conservative Republicans who blocked the bill. All 6 Senate Democrats and 11 moderate Republicans voted YES. The bill will not become law this session. → View full roll call
House Vote — March 9, 2026
HOUSE · Mar 9
39
Yes
HOUSE · Mar 9
28
No
HOUSE · Mar 9
3
Absent

Floor sponsor: Rep. Jon O. Weber (R-Rexburg)  ·  Referred to Senate Local Gov & Taxation  ·  Do Pass March 19

What This Bill Does

H 760 amends Idaho Code 63-602GG — a 2002 law that allowed county commissioners to waive property taxes on affordable housing from nonprofit developers. That original law was rarely used because its requirements were too narrow to deploy in practice.

This bill expands the exemption in two key ways: it opens eligibility to for-profit developers who partner with a nonprofit organization, and it standardizes the affordability threshold at 60% of area median income (AMI) — meaning average rents must be affordable to households earning 60% or less of the county's median income. Developers must verify rent compliance annually with the county assessor.

County commissioners retain discretion — they are not required to grant exemptions. The decision stays local.

The Debate
Supporters Argue
  • Idaho has a documented affordable housing shortage. Tax incentives spur supply without direct state spending.
  • The original 2002 law never worked — the nonprofit-only restriction was too narrow. For-profit capital is needed to build at scale.
  • County commissioners retain full discretion — no mandate. Local communities decide.
  • The 60% AMI requirement is a real affordability standard. Annual rent verification provides accountability.
  • Nonprofit partnership requirement preserves a public-interest check on for-profit participation.
Critics Argue
  • Property tax exemptions shift the burden to other taxpayers — homeowners, small businesses — who make up the difference.
  • The fiscal impact was not fully quantified. Rep. John Gannon (D-Boise) voted to print but said he could not support final passage without a concrete cost estimate.
  • For-profit developers benefit from public tax relief while retaining profits. The nonprofit partnership requirement is minimal — a structural fig leaf.
  • Dominium — a national housing developer — had a lobbyist testify in support. Critics question whether this serves Idaho communities or out-of-state corporate interests.
  • 60% AMI is not the lowest end of affordability. In some Idaho counties, households at 60% AMI are not the most housing-insecure residents.
Context — What Else Happened This Session
📋 The Idaho Ledger — Background Context

H 760 does not exist in isolation. It is moving through the same legislature that — in the same session — killed HB 659, which would have required Idaho sheriffs to participate in federal ICE immigration enforcement (the 287(g) program). HB 659 died 4-5 in the Senate State Affairs Committee in March 2026. A separate immigration bill, S 1260, passed the Senate 29-6 and is now on the House floor.

The connection matters because of who lives and works in Idaho's affordable housing — and who employs them.

Idaho's Agricultural Labor Economy — The Numbers
90%
Of Idaho dairy workers are foreign-born
Idaho Dairymen's Association CEO Rick Naerebout
~50%
Of Idaho dairy workers estimated undocumented
Boise State Public Radio / U of I-WSU study, Feb 2026
40,000
Estimated unauthorized workers in Idaho (±10K)
U of I / WSU economic study, Feb 2026
45%
Projected drop in dairy output if half unauthorized workforce removed
Economists Nadreau & Peterson, Feb 2026
$5.1B
Estimated Idaho GDP loss from 70% deportation scenario
Idaho Capital Sun / Boise State Public Radio, Feb 2026
5
Idaho residents who applied for 7,600+ H-2A ag job openings in 2025
Idaho Farm Bureau Federation CEO Zak Miller

In February 2026 — as immigration enforcement bills were moving through the legislature — the Idaho Dairymen's Association, Idaho Farm Bureau Federation, Idaho Home Builders Association, and commercial developer Ahlquist funded and released a joint economic study arguing that enforcement of immigration law would devastate Idaho's economy. The Idaho Alliance for a Legal Workforce, which represents employers dependent on immigrant labor, backed the report.

Those same industries also opposed E-Verify requirements and other state-level immigration enforcement measures. Idaho Farm Bureau CEO Zak Miller argued that "this is a federal issue" — echoing arguments that helped stall enforcement bills in the legislature.

"We are dependent on an unauthorized workforce," Idaho Dairymen's Association CEO Rick Naerebout told the Idaho Capital Sun.

H 760 — the affordable housing tax exemption — would extend tax breaks for the type of dense, lower-cost housing that is disproportionately occupied by the workforce the same industries say they need. That is a fact. What it means is for Idaho voters to decide.

House Vote Coalition — March 9, 2026

The bill passed with a bipartisan YES coalition that included most House Democrats and a bloc of moderate Republicans. The NO coalition was anchored by the more conservative House Republicans. Notable: the 28-member NO bloc included several legislators who voted YES on immigration enforcement bills.

YES (39): Alfieri, Berch, Bingham, Bruce, Cannon, Cheatum, Church, Cornilles, Dygert, Egbert, Erickson, Fuhriman, Furniss, Galaviz, Gannon, Garner, Hall, Handy, Haws, Healey, Holtzclaw, Mathias, Mendive, Mickelsen, Miller, Mitchell, Nelsen, Petzke, Pohanka, Raybould, Raymond, Redman, Rubel, Sauter, Shepherd, Shirts, Veile, Weber, Wheeler

NO (28): Barbieri, Beiswenger, Boyle, Burgoyne, Cayler, Crane (12), Crane (13), Ehardt, Ehlers, Harris, Hawkins, Hill, Hostetler, Leavitt, Marmon, Monks, Palmer, Pickett, Price, Rasor, Scott, Skaug, Tanner (13), Tanner (14), Thompson, Vander Woude, Wisniewski, Mr. Speaker

Contact the Idaho Senate — Before March 27
35 Idaho State Senators vote on H 760 before session ends March 27. Click any senator to expand their contact info and a sample message you can edit and send.
OR — COPY ALL 35 SENATE EMAILS AT ONCE
Sample message appears when you expand each senator. Edit it freely — personalized messages carry more weight than form letters.
Sources: Idaho State Legislature official journal · Idaho Capital Sun (Feb 16, 2026) · Boise State Public Radio (Feb 17-18, 2026) · Capital Press (Feb 18, 2026) · Spokesman-Review (Feb 26-27, 2026) · Idaho Dairymen's Association CEO Rick Naerebout · Idaho Farm Bureau Federation CEO Zak Miller · University of Idaho / WSU economists Nadreau & Peterson, "The Story of Idaho Labor Markets" (2026) · National Milk Producers Federation